Popular Misconceptions About The Paleo Diet

The Paleo diet often gets criticized, but many criticisms simply stem from myths and misconceptions. This article debunks the top 10 popular misconceptions about the Paleo diet, from “Paleo is just another low-carb fad” to “It’s too expensive.” You’ll discover the truth behind the hype – the diet focuses on high-quality, nutrient-dense whole foods, not just macros or rapid weight loss.

Get the real facts behind the world’s most famous prehistoric diet.

10 Most Common Misconceptions About The Paleo Diet

Ever thought about trying the Paleo diet but heard some confusing statements about it? Don’t worry, lots of people have! We’re going to talk about the common misconceptions about the Paleo diet. It’s like finding out what people think about this diet. Let’s jump in and learn together!

Number 1: The Paleo Diet Is Just Another “Low-Carb Diet”

Unlike trendy low-carb diets, Paleo focuses on eating high-quality, nutrient-dense whole foodsᅳnot just lowering your carb intake. The diet eliminates processed junk like grains, legumes, dairy, and oils since our hunter-gatherer ancestors didn’t have access to those.

But Paleo doesn’t strictly limit carbs or macronutrients. Your carb intake can vary widely depending on whether you fill your plate with lower-carb meats and veggies or higher-carb fruits and tubers. The emphasis is on eating real, minimally processed fareᅳnot macro counting.

Beyond nutrition, the Paleo lifestyle also spotlights lifestyle factors like activity, sleep, sun, and stress reduction for overall wellness. This contrasts with other diets, which often focus narrowly on short-term weight loss at the expense of sustainability.

An interesting study by Masharani published in (2015) states, “We investigated in type 2 diabetes whether a diet similar to that consumed by our pre-agricultural hunter-gatherer ancestors (‘Paleolithic’ type diet) confers health benefits” and found “Paleolithic-type diet improved glucose control and lipid profiles in people with type 2 diabetes compared with a conventional diet.”

Number 2: Giving Up Dairy Means Inadequate Calcium

Contrary to popular belief, dairy isn’t your only ticket to meeting calcium needs. The Paleo diet spotlights non-dairy calcium all-stars like leafy greens and canned fish with bones, nuts, and seeds.

A mere 10-15 minutes of sunshine 3x a week also enables your body to use calcium via vitamin D production better.

Studies confirm Paleo eaters consume plenty of calcium from these whole food sources. Avoiding dairy may even improve calcium retention since milk products can spark inflammation. The Paleo diet provides nutrient-dense fruits, veggies, proteins, and fats—not just calcium—for optimal bone health.

The bottom line? You can easily get adequate, efficiently absorbed calcium from non-dairy whole foods in a well-formulated Paleo plan.


Number 3: Paleo Overloads Protein, Harming Your Kidneys

Once again, they’re wrong! Paleo emphasizes veggies—around one-third of the intake. Fruits, healthy fats, and moderate lean protein balance out the rest. So protein isn’t the main focus on your plate.

For healthy individuals, studies show higher protein intakes don’t damage the kidneys or cause disease. There’s no evidence linking meat or whole food protein sources to impaired function in people without pre-existing conditions.

However, those with current chronic kidney disease may benefit from lower protein.

By avoiding processed foods, added sugars, and unhealthy fats, Paleo actually reduces inflammation and risk factors for kidney disease via nutrient-dense whole foods.

Number 4: Eggs Shoot Up Your Cholesterol

Even though many people say bad things about it, dietary cholesterol from eggs has little effect on blood cholesterol for most individuals. As noted in a study, “Intake of 3 eggs per day regulates cholesterol synthesis without changing the LDL/HDL ratio, maintaining heart disease risk,” eggs may mildly raise both “good” (HDL) and “bad” (LDL) cholesterol types. Still, they do not drive up heart disease risk in healthy people.

This study observed that “higher plasma concentrations of total cholesterol (7.5%), high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) (5%) and LDL-C (8.1%) were observed with egg consumption (p< 0.01), while no change was seen in LDL-C/HDL-C ratio, a key marker of heart disease risk” saturated and trans fats impact cholesterol levels far more than eggs, which contain minimal saturated fat. It’s the bacon and butter that many plop on their eggs that’s more concerning.

Of course, some genetically predisposed individuals and diabetics may be extra sensitive. But for most already eating healthy, eggs cause little cholesterol change.

So fear not, egg lovers! Current research confirms eggs no longer deserve their bad cholesterol levels. For most healthy individuals, they can be part of a balanced diet without adversely affecting blood cholesterol or heart disease odds.

Number 5: The Paleo Diet Is Expensive To Follow

Paleo’s high price tag leaves many hesitant. But does wholesome eating really have to drain your wallet? Not necessarily. With savvy shopping and simple swaps, sticking to your Paleo budget is possible.

This diet centers on basic whole foods—produce, eggs, meat, and fish. Processed snacks and treats quickly inflate costs, not quality ingredients. Plan meals around cheaper produce cuts, eggs, or canned fish instead of pricey steak every night. Buy in bulk, leverage sales, and choose seasonal fare to shave dollars off your bill. Small tweaks add up.

The fact is, Paleo costs stack up similarly against other fresh-focused diets like Mediterranean or intermittent fasting plans. With smart strategies, you can make wholesome Paleo work on a budget.

Number 6: Saying Bye To Bread And Baked Goods On Paleo

Many see giving up their beloved pancakes, waffles, and bread as the biggest roadblock to trying Paleo. But thanks to clever substitutions, you can enjoy grain-free takes on these favorites.

Creative Paleo bakers are whipping up muffins, breads, and tasty baked treats using coconut, cassava, or almond flour rather than wheat. Brands like Birch Benders even offer paleo-friendly pancake and waffle mixes to satisfy your breakfast hankerings.

While not exactly the same texture and taste, these swaps come deliciously close. So you can still indulge those comfort food cravings in a Paleo way.

Number 7: It’s Hard To Prep Paleo Meals

Many see labor-intensive meal prep as a roadblock to trying Paleo. But with efficient planning, you can whip up delicious Paleo cuisine without living in the kitchen.

Numerous Paleo meals come together quickly thanks to simple prep. We’re talking easy stir-fries, sheet pan dinners, salads, and more. Batch cook chicken breasts or hard-boiled eggs on less busy days for instant protein all week. 

Get ahead on time-consuming recipes by making big batches of salads, hearty stews, soups, or casseroles. Portion and freeze for future fast meals. And prep ingredients like chopped veggies in advance to slash daily cooking time.

The Paleo world is now filled with convenient shortcuts, from frozen produce to precooked grilled chicken and more. So, not everything requires homemade from scratch.

Number 8: Paleo Equals All Meat, All the Time

Having a meat-centric image is one of the most popular misconceptions about the Paleo diet that turns many off from trying it. But this diet is far from all steak and bacon, all the time. An array of nourishing foods beyond meat take center stage.

The Paleo diet has plant-based recipes loaded with veggies, fruits, nuts, seeds, and healthy fats—not just animal protein. Meals like stir-fries, egg scrambles, salads, and sheet pan fajitas make veggies the headliner.

Meat and seafood play a key role in supplying protein, iron, and zinc. But they’re balanced out by equal amounts of produce, not overloaded. For those eager to cut back on meat, going “pegan” by emphasizing plants on a Paleo framework is totally possible.

Number 9: Paleo As “The Magic Weight Loss Cure”

Many flock to Paleo, hoping it’s their golden ticket to rapid weight loss. But while dropping pounds may initially occur when you eliminate processed foods, weight loss isn’t the end goal here—it’s a byproduct. This diet targets overall wellness and disease prevention first and foremost.

Eliminating refined carbs and sugars and emphasizing more satiating proteins, fiber, and plant foods can naturally spur calorie reduction. But Paleo doesn’t necessarily require purposefully slashing calories or meticulous macro counting solely for weight control. Research confirms Paleo can enable weight loss for some based on reductions in waist circumference, improved blood sugar regulation, better lipid profiles, and more. But sheer pounds dropped don’t headline the results.

Paleo takes a big-picture view of your lifestyle beyond just food. Sleep, stress management, and physical activity also greatly influence weight and health. Paleo focuses on overall wellness, with weight regulation as a secondary benefit.

Number 10: Paleo As “No-Carb No Man’s Land”

Last but not least, many avoid Paleo, fearing it eliminates carbs completely, like keto. But far from zero-carb territory, this diet openly embraces carbs—just from whole, unprocessed sources.

Our ancestors didn’t just survive on meat and fat alone. Evidence shows they consumed carb-containing honey and starchy tubers, too. So, highly low-carb ideas don’t accurately reflect evolutionary eating.

While Paleo eliminates modern grains and legumes, it actively encourages carb-rich fruits and veggies. You have the flexibility to include healthy carb sources to meet your needs.

Some lower-carb Paleo versions exist for those who prefer that approach. But strictly zero-carb isn’t intrinsic to this nutritional model.

Wrapping Up

To wrap it up, learning about the popular misconceptions about the paleo diet helps clear up confusion and gives us a better understanding of what the diet is really about. By getting rid of wrong ideas and sharing the right information, we can make better choices and follow the Paleo lifestyle with a clearer picture of what it entails. Let’s take steps toward a healthier, more informed journey with Paleo, leaving behind any misconceptions that might have caused confusion.

Don’t miss out on the Paleo fun! Subscribe to our newsletter today for the latest Paleo hacks, articles, and mouthwatering recipes!

Get free weekly recipes directly in your inbox 💌

Popular Misconceptions About The Paleo Diet

Sharing is caring

Related posts